Inching … Siân Shipley on writing Jinny

The sequel to Dream of the Dance is taking longer than I’d hoped, but it is slowly and surely inching in the right direction. I think I’m allowed to mention/reveal the title (with the caveat that if by the time it’s finished, said title doesn’t fit the narrative any more, it’s a working title!). After quite a bit of back and forth, Jane and I decided on False Start, which seems appropriate on so many levels. Not only is it vaguely equestrian in theme (although I promise that Jinny and Shantih don’t suddenly take up racing careers), but Jinny has several of them before finding her feet at Goldsmiths, and I’ve had DOZENS writing it so far — hence the delay. 

Who is Jinny?

I think the thing that’s taking up a lot of my brainpower is trying to keep Jinny her authentic self—the Jinny we all recognise—in an environment which is wholly new and alien to her. Who IS Jinny when she’s not with Shantih? What is it she’s supposed to learn, out there in the world, that she couldn’t possibly have learnt back in the familiar bubble of Finmory? It’s taking shape, but it’s also taking time.

What if?

A lot of that time is spent wondering, “what if, what if, what if?”

What if the Finmory series hadn’t been ended after Running Wild? If Patricia hadn’t had to curtail the series? What if all the threads she had been weaving—the Walker, the Masters he served, the Golden Horses—had continued for ANOTHER twelve books? What more might we have seen? What was it that Patricia was building towards? We’ll never know, and sometimes, honestly, that consumes me. 

Season by Season

Getting to write Season by Season was an unexpected pleasure. A chance to slip back in time, and revisit Jinny as we knew her in the original run. As with Dream of the Dance (and hopefully in False Start, when it finally appears) it’s also been an opportunity for me to clear up a few bits and pieces which always puzzled me, and clarify things which were, for whatever reason, not explicitly stated in Patricia’s original stories (editorial constraints? Adherence to a strict word count? Who knows!).

And also …

Personally, I’ve always wondered about the three Finmory kittens, who disappear promptly after For Love of a Horse (apart from a one-line mention in The Summer Riders) never to be mentioned again — more on those in future outings. Whatever happened to Miss Tuke’s short-lived Trekking Club? Did the Gilberts EVER get their comeuppance, or did their money and privilege mean they slithered away relatively unscathed?

When’s Jinny’s birthday? An unknown aunt gifted her a pair of string gloves for a birthday two years prior to A Devil To Ride, and in Horse of Fire, Mike gave her fabric paints “for her last birthday” but we never get mention of a birthday (or the aunt, or any other extended family member) ever again, and we never see her have one in the whole series. More on that in the future, too! 

The matter of food

Is she or isn’t she vegetarian? This one caused some real head-scratchers when I was writing DOTD, so I decided to make her exclusively veggie in the hope that I’d get to go back and elaborate on it later. The last time we see her eating meat is in the awful guesthouse during Chestnut Gold. In Jump for the Moon there are ambiguous mentions of broth and stew, and whilst it’s never explicitly stated in the later books that she’s made the leap into full-blown vegetarianism (it’s mentioned that she hated the thought of animals being killed for food, but equally, there’s never a qualifier of “so she didn’t eat it any more” or “she had decided to be like Ken”), it certainly reads that way from Horse of Fire onward. Season by Season seemed an excellent opportunity to clear that up. 

An editor’s lot

If you ever get chance, please ask poor, beleaguered Jane about my first draft of Dream of the Dance which was crammed with references to Every. Single. Secondary. Character in the entire Finmory universe. [Editor’s note: it absolutely was.] Nick Webster and family. The Gilberts. The McKenzies. Sara, Tam and the rest of the travellers. Nell Storr. Kat. Clare Burnley. Marlene (and Bill) Thorpe. Sue Horton. The Wrights. Moria. Sarah. The Hay boys. If they were mentioned, I had plans for them, and they were ALL impossibly shoehorned into DOTD in the first instance.

This seemed, to me, entirely reasonable and appropriate, because I spent multiple decades getting to know these people — brilliant and vile alike — and I had OPINIONS about what might have happened to them after the events of their books. Jane however, had to do some very tactful guidance about who should stay and who should go, and helped me take a literary scalpel to some of the stragglers, and I think DOTD is VASTLY better for it. There are three or four scenes I tried valiantly to squeeze in, and although they were great fun to write, really didn’t fit the overall narrative, but that doesn’t mean they might not appear elsewhere in the future.

Siân’s own chestut Arab, Isleem
The loneliness of Jinny

And like her or loathe her (there are passionate supporters in both camps, and I can ABSOLUTELY see the reasons for both), the thing I come back to, again and again, is how LONELY Jinny is. Her friendships are fleeting—Sue, Kat, Nick, Marlene, Tam—or, in the case of Dolina, deeply unsatisfying. Nell leaves for France. Jo Wilton dies. Miss Tuke isn’t a peer, only another grown-up. All she really has is Shantih, and Ken.

Mr and Mrs Manders

Mr and Mrs Manders aren’t the WORST pony book parents by a country mile; in fact, they both have instances where they’re brilliant (Mrs Manders producing the Nativity cloak at the eleventh hour, Mr Manders more generally), but they aren’t always consistent. Mr Manders has concerns about Clare Burnley’s influence on Jinny, yet doesn’t intervene in the slightest to stop it.

Mrs Manders would rather send Shantih to Miss Tuke’s when the building of Inverburgh Comprehensive is delayed, rather than learn to mix a feed and fling it over the fence twice a day—and don’t get me started on the casual way they just assume Marlene Thorpe is safe to ride Shantih when she’s never ridden before, and accuse Jinny of selfishness for not sharing her. This of course is true, in part, but I cannot IMAGINE the fuss that would’ve been caused if Marlene HAD experienced a terrible accident. 

The countryside around Siân

So, so many of Jinny’s own feelings and life experiences are things she has to navigate alone. There’s so much to dig into. So perhaps there may well be another Finmory seasonal short story or two in the offing as False Start continues to take shape, but only if I can be certain that they’d stand on their own merit, and not come off as trite, or reductive. 

I really do hope you enjoy Season by Season, and if there are things about Jinny’s world that ever made you wonder, get in contact! I always love to talk about the what ifs.

***

You can find Siân on her Facebook page, Siân Shipley Writes

Season by Season is out as an eBook on 18 November 2026

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *